Criticism of credit counseling (USA) In the late 1980s and early 1990s, the number of credit and debt counseling agencies in America increased significantly. An antitrust lawsuit was filed against the NFCC, arguing that the presence of creditors on the NFCC’s Board of Directors constituted monopolistic practices. As a result of this litigation, creditors agreed to fund non-NFCC member agencies as well.
These sharp increases of credit counseling activity also created other, more serious issues in the industry. By the early 1990s, abuses by certain credit counseling organizations were so significant, it led to criticism of the entire industry.
A credit counseling agency typically receives most of its compensation from the creditors to whom the debt payments are distributed. This funding relationship has led many to believe that credit counseling agencies are merely a collections wing of the creditors. This fee income, known as “Fair Share,” are contributions from the creditors that originally earned the agency 15% of the amount recovered. However, in recent years, Fair Share contributions have dwindled steadily, with contributions of 4-10% being the most common.
Still the NFCC considers bankcard companies to be one of their primary "constituents," and the NFCC website promotes the fact that they collect $5 billion for creditors each year. It also promotes their efforts to steer consumers away from bankruptcy.
The Federal Trade Commission has filed lawsuits against several credit counseling agencies, and continues to urge caution in choosing a credit counseling agency. The FTC has received more than 8,000 complaints from consumers about credit counselors, many concerning high or hidden fees and the inability to opt out of so-called “voluntary” contributions. The Better Business Bureau also reports high complaint levels about credit counseling.
The IRS also has weighed in on the subject of credit counseling, and has denied nonprofit 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status to around 30 of the nation's 1000 credit counseling agencies. Those 30 credit counseling agencies account for more than half of the industry's revenue. Audits of non-profit credit counseling agencies by the IRS are ongoing.
Other organizations have voiced criticisms of the credit counseling industry, often citing the Fair Share funding model as evidence that credit counselors serve the interests of the creditors over the interests of consumers, and that credit counselors are not forthcoming in speaking out about the actions of creditors for fear of losing what little funding remains. Credit counselors respond that their job is not to take sides but to negotiate with all parties equally to help successfully resolve debts. They further argue that the steady decline in Fair Share funding belies the notion that creditors are in control of the credit counseling industry.
Another common criticism of credit counseling is the assertion that participating in a Debt Management Plan will ruin a consumer’s credit. Fair Isaac Corporation, the company that pioneered the use of credit scores, states that participation in a Debt Management Plan has no effect on a consumer's FICO credit score. However, the participation in such a plan may appear on consumer credit reports, and the client may have more difficulty obtaining a car or home loan and be denied any further unsecured credit, such as a credit card. This is because lenders often use multiple risk factors to determine creditworthiness. The major factor holding consumers back is the amount of debt they have relative to their income (the debt to income ratio) and not enrollment in a credit counseling plan. While credit card banks offering relatively low-credit-line cards may use a credit score alone to approve a new account, a mortgage or car lender typically will scrutinize the entire credit report more extensively and verify employment and income information. Some lenders view a prospective customer's participation in a Debt Management Plan as indicative of the customer being unfit to manage their finances.
Additionally, mortgage loans backed by federal programs such as HUD or FHA have additional government underwriting guidelines in addition to the lender's own policies. HUD/FHA states their position on credit counseling is neutral and that a factor they will consider is whether the client has been adhering to the payment plan initially established through the credit counseling agency.[1] The FHA recommends credit counseling programs to those who fear being denied a mortgage loan due to credit approval.[2]
Counseling agencies have also been criticized for understating their clients' future responsibilities during the initial enrollment process. Agencies have been accused of telling clients to stop paying creditors directly and to then keep the first payment made by the client into the DMP to cover fees. This can result in accounts being charged off during the period that the client transitions into the DMP. Many clients come to the DMP with current accounts; they are simply seeking lower interest rates rather than needing help bringing their accounts current. Since a DMP is designed for consumers who are having trouble meeting obligations it is usually the case that any consumer joining a DMP already has past due accounts. For consumers who do not have past due accounts they must be aware that creditors will carry them past due since that creditor is giving the consumer a concession on the amount of interest charged. In this way a client's credit can be damaged as the accounts unintentionally fall past due.
Given this criticism, the industry is likely to be changed forever in the immediate future as it is scrutinized by both the consumer and government regulators over how they will be paid for the services they perform. In meantime, there will be no shortage of debt-burdened consumers who will now be facing a burgeoning, and more traditional, collection industry.
Welcome To Bed & Breakfast In Barcelona Situated near some of the most interesting points of barcelona, you will find ours familiar bed and breakfast and guest house. We offer our guests a warm, polite but friendly stay.
Roofers Contractors Sugar Land Texas Our roofing contractors are the most distinguished in sugar land, tx. We offer speedy and efficient services; from fixing leaks and damaged roofs, to custom roofs such as metal, tile, asphalt, and wood roofs. Call our roofing experts now 2818576537!
Residential Roofing Contractor West University Texas West university roofers are professional and expedient. We serve houston, tx in roof leaks and roof patch emergencies, we know what hail damage and high winds will do to your roof. We will do roof removal and re-roof for you. Call now, 7135893689
Roof Leak Repair Contractors Our prestigious roofing contractors serve you in any roofing need; leaks, hail damage and storm damage, restorations, roof removal and roof installations. If you are in pearland, texas and surrounding tx area and need roofing help, call now 281857642
Tropical Storm Hermine Claims Lawyer Our tropical storm hermine attorneys understand the devastation's you have gone through. Having gone through enough, we take the stress out of getting money you deserve. We handle hail, wind, hurricane and fire damage cases. We help texas 9565254162
Car Accident Lawyer San Antonio Our top notch personal injury lawyers are here to help san antonio, tx with any needs starting from; car accidents, workplace injuries, oil and gas injuries, to drowning and product liability cases. If you need help call our lawyers now 2108588069
Horecapolis Le monde du materiel de grande cuisine au petite prix
Halong Bay Tours Offers you many options to visit and stay in halong bay. We are a tour operator who specializes in halong bay junk tours
Disclaimer Legal Information Is Not Legal Advice This site provides information about the law designed to help users safely cope with their own legal needs. But legal information is not the same as legal advice -- the application of law to an individual's specific circumstances. Although we go to great lengths to make sure our information is accurate and useful, we recommend you consult a lawyer if you want professional assurance that our information, and your interpretation of it, is appropriate to your particular situation.
Consumer Credit Counseling Information, Debt Management Plan Information, Debt Settlement Plan information, Credit Counseling, Credit Score, Consumer Credit Counseling Service, CCCS, Bill Consolidation, Credit Repair, and Debt Consolidation is not advice, and we recommend you consult a licensed credit counseling agency, debt settlement attorney, and/or licensed debt management plan administrator in your state if you want professional assurance that our information, and your interpretation of it, is appropriate to your particular situation.
